Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Doug's avatar

Your opinions on food, like many of yours on politics, disgust me. This is why I am a subscriber.

Expand full comment
CityCalmDown's avatar

Possibly the most extreme form of self-denying, self-negating self-deprivation is the Jain practice of Sallekhana. This ritualistic process of gradually withdrawing forms of nutrition from the practitioner's diet until he or she finally expires is an activity that involves the entire Jain community and can take a number of months to fully complete.

https://bigthink.com/thinking/extreme-asceticism-the-jains-who-starve-themselves-to-death/

Jains insist that Sallekhana is a practice of religious Enlightenment and that it is *not* a form of suicide.

For Jains, Sallekhana is a central part of their soteriological traditions. They stress that the essential salvific aspects emanate beyond the individual undergoing the ritual and are transmitted throughout both the entire Jain community and beyond this into the social world of which the Jains are a part. This salvific effect distinguishes the Sallekhana form of intense corporeal self-negation from acts of suicide. Suicide is illegal in India as is, for the moment., Jainist Sallekhana despite their efforts to fight this criminalization.

"It is argued that it is suicide since there is voluntary severance of life etc. No, it is not suicide, as there is no passion. Without attachment etc, there is no passion in this undertaking. A person who kills himself by means of poison, weapon, etc, swayed by attachment, aversion or infatuation, commits suicide. But he who practices holy death is free from desire, anger, and delusion. Hence it is not suicide"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sallekhana#Legality_and_comparison_with_suicide

Did Simone Weil commit suicide? When Weil insisted that it was only ethical to eat as much as the average calorie allotment of the typical French adult during WWII even as her doctors told her that she would thereby fatally injure her health, how are we to understand her final days?

Though Weil experienced several intense mystical states in the course of her life, she was never comfortable converting to the official Catholic Church. Weil's mystical experiences were often associated with intense pain - migraines - and/or exhaustion - factory work. In her final days of ill health and self-imposed malnutrition, what final insights and visions did Weil hope to attain?

Expand full comment
32 more comments...

No posts